Pi Shuang

Star

Arsenolite / arsenic trioxide (As2O3)

Not yet clinically reviewed

Pinyin: Pi Shuang
Arsenic

Traditionally used for

  • Cough & breathing
  • Bowel health
  • Skin

Cautions & contraindications

  • Pregnancy
  • Heart conditions
  • Toxic — professional use only
Moderate evidence · 6 studies

☯ TCM Properties

Category: external applications
Temperature: neutral
Taste: pungent, sour
Meridians: spleen, lung, liver
Functions:

Eliminates phlegm and calms dyspnea; Prevents malaria; Kills parasites and erodes sores topically

Traditional Chinese Uses

Pi Shuang is refined arsenic trioxide (As2O3, "arsenic frost"), a highly toxic mineral substance prepared by sublimation of arsenical ores. Pungent and sour (classically noted as hot) and entering the Spleen, Lung and Liver channels, it was traditionally used in minute, carefully processed doses to transform cold Phlegm and calm wheezing in chronic asthma, to check malarial disorders, and to kill parasites. Topically it erodes rotten flesh and toxic sores, and was applied to obstinate ulcers, scrofula, tinea, hemorrhoids and abnormal granulation tissue.

This is a poison of the highest order: arsenic destroys cellular respiration, damages the liver and gastrointestinal tract, and is readily lethal. It is strictly contraindicated in pregnancy and in weak patients, must never be self-used, and its manufacture and sale are legally restricted. Historical and modern hospital-supervised use only.

Click a node for details · double-click to expand it · Ctrl/⌘ + scroll or two fingers to zoom and pan.

Loading graph…

Botanical Description

Pi Shuang is the Chinese name for refined arsenic trioxide (As2O3), historically prepared by sublimation of arsenical ores such as arsenolite or realgar (Pi Shi). It appears as a white, crystalline, odorless powder, extremely toxic in even minute oral doses, with a recorded fatal dose under 100 mg. Classical Chinese materia medica employed Pi Shuang externally for malignant ulcers and obstinate skin lesions, and internally in trace amounts within compound formulas for chronic asthma and certain malignancies. Modern pharmacology has confirmed activity of arsenic trioxide against acute promyelocytic leukemia, where it is administered as a tightly controlled pharmaceutical (Trisenox). Unregulated internal use is universally discouraged due to severe systemic toxicity, carcinogenicity, and risk of fatal poisoning.

Active Constituents

Arsenic trioxide (As2O3)

Inorganic trivalent arsenic oxide

Concentration: Essentially the whole drug; Pi Shuang is the sublimed, refined product and is close to pure As2O3, whereas the crude parent ore Pi Shi (also called Xin Shi or Ren Yan) is more variable and carries ore residues

This single compound accounts for both the drug's activity and its lethality; there is no separable therapeutic fraction. Arsenite binds vicinal thiol pairs in proteins, inhibiting pyruvate dehydrogenase and thioredoxin reductase, and it binds a cysteine-rich region of the PML moiety of the PML-RARA fusion protein, driving its SUMOylation and degradation, which is the basis of the licensed leukaemia indication. The acute human lethal dose of arsenic trioxide is conventionally placed in the region of 1 to 3 mg per kg body weight, only a few multiples of the traditional internal dose, and inorganic arsenic is classified by IARC in Group 1 as carcinogenic to humans.

Arsenolite

Cubic mineral polymorph of As2O3

Concentration: The named source mineral of the crude drug

Arsenolite is the cubic mineral form of arsenic trioxide, formed as a secondary oxidation product on arsenopyrite, realgar and orpiment ores, or by roasting them. It is appreciably water-soluble for a mineral, which is precisely why ingested material is well absorbed and why the drug is dangerous rather than inert.

Claudetite

Monoclinic mineral polymorph of As2O3

Concentration: Accessory phase in weathered arsenical ore

The monoclinic polymorph of arsenic trioxide, chemically identical to arsenolite and toxicologically indistinguishable from it once dissolved. Its presence is a mineralogical rather than a pharmacological distinction.

Residual arsenic sulfides (realgar As4S4, orpiment As2S3)

Arsenic sulfide minerals

Concentration: Variable; higher in the red grade Hong Pi than in the white grade Bai Pi, and the source of the red or yellow tint

Incompletely roasted sulfide ore leaves realgar and orpiment in the crude product; these are far less soluble than the oxide but add to the total arsenic burden and can be converted to arsenic trioxide by further heating. Their proportion is what distinguishes the coloured commercial grades, so grade is a crude and unreliable proxy for potency.

Antimony, lead, iron and sulfur ore residues

Contaminant metals and metalloids from the parent ore

Concentration: Trace to percent level, unstandardised in the crude drug

Arsenical ores are typically polymetallic, so crude arsenolite carries an unquantified secondary burden of other toxic elements. Analyses of Asian patent medicines have repeatedly found undeclared arsenic, mercury and lead together in the same preparation, which means a crude arsenical cannot be assumed to be a single-element exposure.

⚠ Drug Interactions

QT-prolonging drugs (Class Ia and Class III antiarrhythmics, methadone, ondansetron, fluoroquinolones, azole antifungals)

Major Evidence: Established

Arsenic trioxide prolongs cardiac repolarisation. In a review of serial ECGs from 99 patients given 170 courses of intravenous arsenic trioxide, QT prolongation developed in 38 patients, of whom 26 reached a QTc of 500 ms or more (Barbey 2003), and a later prospective single-institution series found QTc above 500 ms in a comparable share of APL patients (Roboz 2014). Any co-administered QT-prolonging agent is additive on the same substrate. This is a class effect of absorbed arsenite and is not confined to the pharmaceutical preparation.

Clinical note: Do not combine. Where arsenic is being given at all it belongs in a setting with baseline and serial ECGs, and this is not achievable with an unstandardised crude mineral dosed at home.

Loop and thiazide diuretics, amphotericin B and other drugs causing hypokalaemia or hypomagnesaemia

Major Evidence: Established

Torsadogenic risk from arsenic rises steeply with low serum potassium and magnesium. Haematology protocols for arsenic trioxide require potassium and magnesium to be corrected and maintained before and during each infusion, and the reported cases of torsade during arsenic therapy cluster in patients with electrolyte disturbance or concurrent QT-prolonging drugs (Barbey 2003; Roboz 2014).

Clinical note: Treat any patient on diuretics as at high risk. Crude arsenicals also cause vomiting and diarrhoea, which generates the same electrolyte loss without any monitoring.

Dimercaprol, unithiol (DMPS) and succimer (DMSA)

Major Evidence: Established

Dithiol chelators are the standard treatment for acute and chronic inorganic arsenic poisoning and act by competing for the same vicinal thiol binding that arsenite exploits. In documented poisoning from Chinese mineral medicines containing lead tetraoxide, arsenic and mercury, DMPS produced only partial recovery and peripheral neuropathy persisted four years later (Wu 2013). The corollary is that a patient taking a chelator for any reason has an unpredictable arsenic exposure, and a patient on therapeutic arsenic trioxide must not be chelated without haematology direction.

Clinical note: Chelation is a hospital decision, guided by blood and 24-hour urine arsenic with speciation. Do not initiate or continue a herbal arsenical alongside it.

All-trans retinoic acid (tretinoin)

Major Evidence: Established

The combination of all-trans retinoic acid with intravenous arsenic trioxide is the licensed, chemotherapy-free standard of care in low-to-intermediate risk acute promyelocytic leukaemia and was non-inferior and then superior to ATRA plus chemotherapy in a randomised trial (Lo-Coco 2013). Both agents drive differentiation of the malignant promyelocyte clone and both can precipitate differentiation syndrome, which is managed with pre-emptive corticosteroids in a haematology unit. The combination has no application outside diagnosed APL, and the crude mineral is not an acceptable source of the arsenic component.

Clinical note: Relevant only to haematology practice. A patient on ATRA is by definition under specialist care; do not add any arsenical outside that protocol.

Realgar (Xiong Huang) and realgar-containing patent medicines such as Niu Huang Jie Du Pian and An Gong Niu Huang Wan

Major Evidence: Established

Realgar-containing patent medicines are sold over the counter across Asia and their arsenic content is frequently not stated on the label; heating realgar converts arsenic sulfide to arsenic trioxide, so the two drugs converge chemically. Analyses of Asian patent medicines have found undeclared arsenic in a substantial minority of products (Ko 1998), and mouse and cell-culture work confirms that realgar-containing Niu Huang Jie Du Pian delivers real arsenical toxicity rather than being inert (Miao 2011). A patient taking Pi Shuang alongside such products is receiving an additive arsenic burden that nobody has counted.

Clinical note: Take a full over-the-counter and patent-medicine history before any arsenical is considered, and count the total arsenic, not the number of prescriptions.

Dosage

Form Amount Frequency Duration Population Notes
topical Appropriate amount — — — No Chinese Pharmacopoeia 2025 monograph for this drug, so no pharmacopoeial dose is given here. EXTERNAL USE ONLY in traditional practice, applied in minute quantity to malignant sores and to devitalise tooth pulp. Arsenic trioxide (As₂O₃) is a Group 1 human carcinogen and acutely lethal in the low-milligram range; the traditional internal doses are in single milligrams and are outside the scope of this record. **Dose not established here — do not infer one.** Modern medicinal use of arsenic trioxide (for acute promyelocytic leukaemia) is intravenous, hospital-supervised, and unrelated to the herbal drug. The previous value was generic filler generated from tcm_category and has been removed rather than replaced with an estimate.

Evidence Tier

Moderate evidence · 6 studies

Recorded studies by study design, strongest design at the top. This is a study-design tier only, not a GRADE rating: it does not weigh risk of bias, consistency or precision.

Verified: design read from PubMed for a DOI that resolves to the cited paper Unverified: taken from the study's recorded description

Clinical Studies

Retinoic Acid and Arsenic Trioxide for Acute Promyelocytic Leukemia

Lo-Coco F, Avvisati G, Vignetti M, Thiede C, Orlando SM, Iacobelli S, et al. (2013) New England Journal of Medicine RCT Verified: Randomized controlled trial

Phase 3 randomised non-inferiority trial in 162 adults with newly diagnosed low-to-intermediate risk acute promyelocytic leukaemia comparing all-trans retinoic acid plus intravenous arsenic trioxide with ATRA plus idarubicin. Two-year event-free survival was 97 percent with ATRA-arsenic versus 86 percent with ATRA-chemotherapy, establishing the chemotherapy-free arsenic regimen as standard of care. This is the evidence base for pharmaceutical-grade arsenic trioxide given intravenously under haematology supervision with cardiac and electrolyte monitoring; it says nothing in favour of the crude mineral taken by mouth.

Complete Remission after Treatment of Acute Promyelocytic Leukemia with Arsenic Trioxide

Soignet SL, Maslak P, Wang ZG, Jhanwar S, Calleja E, Dardashti LJ, et al. (1998) New England Journal of Medicine cohort

Single-arm pilot study of intravenous arsenic trioxide in 12 patients with relapsed acute promyelocytic leukaemia; 11 achieved complete remission, with degradation of the PML-RARA protein demonstrated in patient cells. This is the report that carried arsenic from Chinese hospital practice into international haematology, and it also documents the adverse profile, including QT prolongation and a leucocytosis resembling the retinoic acid syndrome.

Use of Arsenic Trioxide (As2O3) in the Treatment of Acute Promyelocytic Leukemia (APL): II. Clinical Efficacy and Pharmacokinetics in Relapsed Patients

Shen ZX, Chen GQ, Ni JH, Li XS, Xiong SM, Qiu QY, et al. (1997) Blood cohort

Chinese single-arm series of 15 patients with relapsed acute promyelocytic leukaemia treated with intravenous arsenic trioxide, of whom 14 achieved complete remission, with pharmacokinetic measurement of plasma arsenic. Toxicity was described as mild at the doses used, but the report concerns a purified 0.1 percent aqueous arsenic trioxide solution infused in hospital, not an orally dosed mineral.

Effect of Arsenic Trioxide on QT Interval in Patients With Advanced Malignancies

Barbey JT, Pezzullo JC, Soignet SL (2003) Journal of Clinical Oncology cohort

Review of clinical data and serial electrocardiograms from 99 patients who received 170 courses of arsenic trioxide in phase 1 and phase 2 studies. QT prolongation developed in 38 patients, with 26 reaching a QTc of 500 ms or more, and the effect was dose-related and reversible between courses. This is the primary human evidence for the cardiac hazard of absorbed arsenite and the reason arsenic therapy requires ECG and electrolyte monitoring.

Prevalence, Management, and Clinical Consequences of QT Interval Prolongation During Treatment With Arsenic Trioxide

Roboz GJ, Ritchie EK, Carlin RF, Samuel M, Gale L, Provenzano-Gober JL, et al. (2014) Journal of Clinical Oncology cohort

Single-institution analysis of patients receiving arsenic trioxide under a protocol of aggressive electrolyte repletion and serial ECGs. QTc exceeded 500 ms in a substantial minority of patients, but with monitoring and potassium and magnesium correction no episodes of torsade de pointes or arsenic-attributed cardiac death occurred, and treatment rarely had to be stopped. The finding is that the hazard is manageable only where monitoring exists.

Lead, Mercury, and Arsenic Poisoning Due to Topical Use of Traditional Chinese Medicines

Wu ML, Deng JF, Lin KP, Tsai WJ (2013) The American Journal of Medicine cohort Verified: Observational / case report

Two toxicologically confirmed cases of systemic heavy-metal poisoning from mucocutaneous rather than oral use of Chinese mineral medicines. A 51-year-old man who applied a hong-dan mixture containing lead tetraoxide, arsenic and mercury into an anal fistula for two weeks developed perianal gangrene, rash, anaemia, hair loss, peripheral neuropathy and muscle atrophy, with raised urine arsenic and mercury; DMPS chelation gave only partial recovery and the neuropathy persisted four years later. The authors conclude that short-term application of these preparations to damaged or infected tissue causes serious systemic poisoning, which directly undercuts the assumption that external use of an arsenical is safe.

⚠ Rule-Based Cautions

These entries come from the deterministic rule tables that gate Verscienta's formula tools — classical pair prohibitions, pregnancy and lactation contraindications, and dose ceilings.

Incompatibilities (十八反 / 十九畏)

  • 十九畏: Shui Yin × Pi Shuang — avoid combining with Shui Yin / Mercury

Historical Texts

Ri Hua Zi Ben Cao (Ri Hua Zi's Materia Medica)

Five Dynasties period, tenth century CE
Among the earliest materia medica citations for pi shi, recorded for intermittent fever (malaria) and for kidney qi. The drug enters the written record already labelled toxic.

Ben Cao Gang Mu (Compendium of Materia Medica), Li Shizhen, stone section, entry for pi shi

Ming dynasty, compiled to 1578, first printed 1596
Gives the alternative names xin shi and ren yan, and makes the distinction that still defines the two drugs: the raw ore is called pi huang while the refined, sublimed product is called pi shuang. Li Shizhen classes it as you da du, gravely toxic, and the doses he quotes are single grains the size of a mung bean. Xin shi takes its name from Xinzhou in what is now Jiangxi, the historical source of the ore.

Yiliao Yong Duxing Yaopin Guanli Banfa (Measures for the Administration of Toxic Drugs for Medical Use), State Council Decree No. 23

People's Republic of China, promulgated 27 December 1988
Not a classical text but the governing modern legal position, and it is the only one there is: neither pi shi nor pi shuang carries a crude-drug monograph in Part I of the 2020 Chinese Pharmacopoeia, so there is no current national assay, dose limit or toxicity labelling for the drug as such. Both pi shi (in its red and white grades) and pi shuang are, however, named in the schedule of 28 toxic Chinese medicinal substances subject to restricted handling, dispensing and record-keeping. The same decree separately schedules arsenic trioxide and potassium arsenite among controlled Western drugs, which is the regulatory expression of the distinction between the crude mineral and the licensed pharmaceutical. In Hong Kong, both Arsenolite and Arsenic Trioxide appear among the nine minerals in Schedule 1 of the Chinese Medicine Ordinance (Cap. 549) and may be supplied only on the prescription of a registered Chinese medicine practitioner. Separately, purified arsenic trioxide for injection has been licensed since 2000 in the United States as Trisenox for acute promyelocytic leukaemia, given intravenously by haematologists with ECG and electrolyte monitoring, with boxed warnings for differentiation syndrome and cardiac conduction abnormalities. That licensed product and this crude mineral are not interchangeable in any direction.

References

  1. IARC Working Group on the Evaluation of Carcinogenic Risks to Humans. Arsenic, Metals, Fibres, and Dusts . IARC Monographs on the Evaluation of Carcinogenic Risks to Humans, Volume 100C (2012)
  2. Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR). Toxicological Profile for Arsenic . U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, Atlanta GA (2007)
  3. Ko RJ. Adulterants in Asian Patent Medicines . New England Journal of Medicine (1998) [DOI]
  4. State Council of the People's Republic of China. Yiliao Yong Duxing Yaopin Guanli Banfa (Measures for the Administration of Toxic Drugs for Medical Use), State Council Decree No. 23 . Government of the People's Republic of China (1988)
  5. Chinese Medicine Regulatory Office, Department of Health, Hong Kong SAR. General Knowledge of Toxic Chinese Herbal Medicines: the 31 toxic Chinese herbal medicines in Schedule 1 of the Chinese Medicine Ordinance (Cap. 549) . Chinese Medicine Regulatory Office, Hong Kong SAR Government (2024)
  6. Miao JW, Liang SX, Wu Q, Liu J, Sun AS. Toxicology Evaluation of Realgar-Containing Niu-Huang-Jie-Du Pian as Compared to Arsenicals in Cell Cultures and in Mice . ISRN Toxicology (2011) [DOI]

This information is for educational purposes only and is not intended to replace professional medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare provider before using any herbal remedy, especially if you are pregnant, nursing, or taking medications.

📝 Notes

Public notes from the community and your own private notes on Pi Shuang.

No notes yet.

Log in or register to add your own notes.

Back to Herb Database