Compare Formulas

Put up to 4 formulas side by side — dose-weighted nature, taste balance and channel reach, with the composition behind them.

Zi Shui Qing Gan Yin Tiao Yuan Shen Qi Wan

How are Zi Shui Qing Gan Yin and Tiao Yuan Shen Qi Wan connected? →

滋水清肝饮 · Zi Shui Qing Gan Yin

Tiao Yuan Shen Qi Wan

Energetics (dose-weighted)
Net nature
Cold Cool Neutral Warm Hot

Net cool (-0.77)

From 100% of the weighed grams.

cold cool neutral warm

Grams by band: cold 28%, cool 36%, neutral 21%, warm 15%.

Small but decisive: Ze Xie 6g (cold, 4% of the grams), Zhi Zi 9g (cold, 6% of the grams). Dose weighting nearly cancels a herb this small, but it may be what the formula is for.

Cold Cool Neutral Warm Hot

Net slightly cool (-0.68)

From 100% of the weighed grams.

cold cool neutral warm

Grams by band: cold 41%, cool 10%, neutral 26%, warm 24%.

Small but decisive: Ze Xie 30g (cold, 5% of the grams), Mai Men Dong 30g (cold, 5% of the grams), Di Gu Pi 30g (cold, 5% of the grams), Huang Bai 15g (cold, 3% of the grams), Zhi Mu 15g (cold, 3% of the grams). Dose weighting nearly cancels a herb this small, but it may be what the formula is for.

Taste
pungent sweet sour bitter bland
  • pungent 11%
  • sweet 31%
  • sour 19%
  • bitter 33%
  • bland 6%

From 100% of the weighed grams.

pungent sweet sour bitter bland
  • pungent 10%
  • sweet 45%
  • sour 10%
  • bitter 25%
  • bland 10%

From 100% of the weighed grams.

Channels reached
  • Liver 68%
  • Kidney 57%
  • Spleen 49%
  • Heart 45%
  • Lung 28%
  • Pericardium 9%

Share of the grams entering each channel, from 100% of the weighed grams.

  • Kidney 88%
  • Heart 61%
  • Liver 56%
  • Spleen 39%
  • Lung 38%
  • Stomach 11%

Share of the grams entering each channel, from 100% of the weighed grams.

Left out 1 not profiled, 1 not weighed None
Composition
Chief herbs — —
Herbs 11 15
Total weight 141.0 g 588.0 g
Source
Classical source Gao Gu Feng's formula Wai Ke Zheng Zong
Dynasty — —

Energetics are dose-weighted from each herb's recorded nature, taste and channels; herbs without a record are left out, never counted as neutral, and a net nature is withheld when its chief herb has none. Classical formulas often pair warm and cool herbs on purpose — a net figure summarises the mix, it doesn't judge it.

Educational reference only — not medical advice. Blank cells mean nothing is recorded, not that a property is absent.